Home

Comparing the Denison Map and RI Archives Map

Leave a comment

The Denison Map of the Battle of Rhode Island is filled with information. I generally look for specific pieces of information from this gem, but today I am going to methodically go through the information it provides. As I go through this map, I am comparing it to the map from the General Sullivan Collection that is in the state archives. I am noting that the handwriting and comments are very similar.

Looking at the Denison map in general there is a compass on the left hand side. There is a scale for two miles and there is a legend of sorts for the positions of the American commanders. The mapmaker lists himself as J. Denison “Scripsit” which means writer. The map covers the areas and dates involved in the “Rhode Island Campaign” – mainly Aquidneck Island and the surrounding waterways. Notes on the bottom of the map tell us that the original is at the Massachusetts Historical Society and that this version is a copy. A note at the bottom provides a legend for symbols in color in the original.

The legend for the battle positions is given at the bottom.

First Line:

G is for Glover, Gr is for Greene, C is for Cornell, V is for Varnum.

Second Line: T is for Titcomb, L is for Lovell.

Reserve: W is West

Flanking Divisions: L is for Livingston and Tyler

The Archives map has no key, but it does have a compass and scale. The names of the commanders are written out, but the positions are the same as in the Denison map.

Comments comparison:

By Howland Ferry: Denison: Here the American Army landed August 9th 1778 beginning half after 6 o’clock A.M. and retreated the 30th in the evening.

By Howland Ferry: Archives: Here the American Army landed August 9th 1778 beginning half after 6 o’clock A.M. and retreated the 30th in the evening.

The comments close to Union Street about the beginning of the battle were the same. :

The comments between East Main and West Main are the same.

What is different is that the Denison map has notations on the French Fleet. These are absent from the Archives map:

On the Sakonnet: “French ships going out to join the French Fleet going to Boston, August 20, 1778.”

In Newport Harbor”. “French fleet going out in pursuit of the British Fleet August 10th 1778, which were then at anchor Near Point Judith.”

By Hog Island: “British ships firing on the American Troops in time of Battle August 29, 1778.”

There is no Author statement on the Archive’s map, but I believe both maps were drawn by J Denison. The Dennison map is more finished. The Archive map looks to be more a record taken at that time and the basis for the Denison map. Perhaps others were aware that these two maps are basically the same, but this was revelation to me. I am still trying to find out about the mapmaker, j Denison. I would appreciate any information about him. He is credited with many more maps through the years.

Maps as an Information Source : Argomaps – Map of the Seconnet Passage

Leave a comment

I have come across an excellent source that gives us easy access to many of the maps of the Revolutionary Rhode Island era. https://www.argomaps.org/about/ is the link to this great source.

From their website:

ARGO: American Revolutionary Geographies Online is a new project led by the Leventhal Map and Education Center at the Boston Public Library and the George Washington Presidential Library at Mount Vernon. Leveraging new technology and the recent drive by many museums, libraries, and archives to digitize their collections, the portal collates digitized maps of North America made between 1750 and 1800 into a single user-friendly portal. In addition to providing users from many backgrounds with easy, intuitive access to beautiful high-resolution images, ARGO seeks to give users of all kinds the tools they need to learn and understand through interpretive essays, curated collections, classroom materials, and more. As a platform for scholarship, education, and exploration, the goal of ARGO is to make the rich visual legacy of our Revolutionary past accessible to the public as never before.”

ARGO’s Advice on using maps as a primary source.

Our number one piece of advice? Take time to look. Just as you would read and reread any other primary source document, be sure to examine your selected map. You can look over the map with the following questions in mind:

What does the map focus on?
How did the maker get you to focus? Did they use color? Are some things larger than others (scale)? What is at the center of the map? What features are accompanied by text?
What is overlooked? What is unlabeled, at the edges, or missing altogether?
How is the map intended to be used? To show political boundaries? Navigation? Sharing data? Depicting a particular place for promotion or propaganda?

What i do:

  1. I always look at the cataloguing information. It usually gives me such information as who the mapmaker was, when was it made, size, etc. Who the mapmaker was can tell us something about the intention of the map.
  2. I do look at the whole map, but I also break it down and specifically take note of what is in sections. Usually I look at the map in four sections. That helps me to notice minor details that may be important.
  3. I try to find a map of the same location today. Names change. McCorrie Point is frequently referred to as “Sandy Point” at the time.
  4. I always look for detail like the compass for orientation, scale, and legend. If this map is a rough sketch, these items might not be present.

Here is an example of how I work with a map that is new to me.

Checking out the bibliographic information.

What information can I cull?

Author: signed H.C. – this is in the Henry Clinton collection

Title: Taken from the back of the map.

Size: about 16 by 13 inches.

Materials: Pen and ink

Notes: Depth soundings are listed. Are they in fathoms? At one location the “Feet” is listed. American and British redoubts are included.

Now I have some information to bring to viewing the actual map. https://www.argomaps.org/maps/commonwealth-oai:hd76wz10d/

My observations: Although this map has a scale and a compass, it doesn’t have a legend, maker’s name or date. It seems to be a utilitarian map prepared for those defending the East coast of the Sakonnet. The passage depths listed and the scale helps defenders pinpoint locations where the Americans are most likely to cross. There is a special note about the redoubt at the Mill Pond – how it is armed and what weapons they have. As I expected, “Sandy Point” on the map is what we call McCorrie Point. There is even a tracing of what the point is like at low tide. American and British redoubts are listed. It would be good to compare them to other maps to get a sense of the dating of this map. The ferry locations are also listed.

On the Map : Siege of Newport and Battle of Rhode Island

Leave a comment

Maps are wonderful primary sources. I have begun collecting as many Revolutionary Era maps as I can. The Clinton Collection of the Clement Library and the Collection of the Library of Congress have some maps that help us understand the actions in the Siege of Newport and the Battle of Rhode Island. The Huntington Library Map of North Portsmouth helps us to understand a British perspective of the battle. I will post more as I find them. I urge you to go to the embeded URL to go to the map directly and use the zoom feature to travel around the map. It is in examining the map close up that we find our most intriguing information.

Fage August 1778 British Defenses (Clement Library- Clinton Collection)

https://quod.lib.umich.edu/w/wcl1ic/x-6052/wcl006125

Plan of the Works – Fage- Defense of Newport – Clinton Collection of Clement Library

https://quod.lib.umich.edu/w/wcl1ic/x-8373/wcl008443

Fage – After the Battle: 29 August – Clinton Collection – Clement Library

https://quod.lib.umich.edu/w/wcl1ic/x-8379/wcl008450

Huntington Library Map after Battle

https://cdm16003.contentdm.oclc.org/digital/collection/p15150coll4/id/16295/rec/3

Attacks upon Rhode Island, Augt. [1778] Map. https://www.loc.gov/item/gm71000685/.
Library of Congress: Attacks Upon Rhode Island

Butts Hill Fort on the Map

2 Comments

We are collecting maps and blueprints that give us an image of Butts Hill Fort. If you have one to add to our collection, let me know, we would be happy to have it. Maps and diagrams are such an important primary source and we can learn from them.

1849 Hammett Map
Plan von Rhode Island, und deren dem comando des Herrn General Majors Presgott inf dies-malig befundlichen campements.

Schiffer, J. C. 1777
Created / Published
[1777]
Subject Headings
Rhode Island (R.I. : Island)–Defenses–Maps, Manuscript–Early works to 1800
[Plan de la ville, du port, et de la rade de New-port et Rhode Island. Debarquement en 1780.
Huntington Library Map – British 1778
Map drawn by Frederick Mackenzie, Summer 1778
Lawton Map circa 1907